Part of: ICF Homes in Ontario

ICF facts and myths

ICF Myths: Fire, Termites, Ants and Mice Answered

Foam burns, concrete does not, and the code makes us cover the foam inside. Bugs and mice do not eat foam, but they will tunnel and nest in it if the details let them. Both problems are solved by doing the boring details right.

I hear these two worries at almost every first meeting. Here is what the fire ratings really mean, what the code requires, where termites actually live in Ontario, and the checks we make before the dirt goes back against the wall.

Fire

FOAM BURNS. CONCRETE DOES NOT.

Let me be straight: the foam on an ICF wall is a plastic and it will burn if you hold a flame to it long enough. Anybody who tells you ICF is “fireproof” is selling something. What matters is what holds the house up, and in an ICF wall that is a solid core of reinforced concrete.

ICF makers have their wall assemblies tested and listed for fire resistance. That rating is how long a wall keeps doing its job in a standard furnace test. Nudura’s Canadian listing, for example, gives:

Concrete core Listed fire-resistance rating
4 inches (102 mm) 2 hours
6 inches (152 mm) 4 hours

Those ratings are for the full assembly in the listing, including 1/2-inch gypsum board fastened to the webs as specified. Other brands publish their own listings. Ask your builder for the one that matches your forms.

Now the honest part. The walls are not the whole house. Floors, roof framing, furniture and contents burn the same as in any home, so smoke alarms, CO alarms and a sensible layout still matter most. Where ICF helps is that the exterior walls stay standing and do not feed the fire.

Bottom line: ICF walls carry real, tested fire ratings because of the concrete. The foam has to be covered, and the rest of the house still needs the usual fire safety.

Code

Drywall Is the Thermal Barrier the Code Requires

The building code says foam plastic insulation in a wall has to be protected from the inside of the house. In plain English: you cannot leave the foam bare on the room side. The national model code’s Part 9 rule, Article 9.10.17.10, accepts the normal interior finishes such as drywall, and certain other barriers. Ontario’s code follows the same approach. Your building inspector will look for it at final.

The question I get is about the basement. “It is unfinished, can I leave the foam bare for now?” In 2023 the BC Building Code Appeal Board ruled on exactly that and said the exposed ICF foam in an unfinished basement still had to be covered, because a basement with stairs and a door is a space people use, not a crawl space. Ontario townships tend to see it the same way, but ask your building department.

  • Budget for drywall in the basement even if you will not finish it for years.
  • Crawl spaces and attics are treated differently. Ask before you assume.
  • Outside, the foam needs cladding or a finish anyway, because sunlight breaks foam down.

The upside: drywall screws straight to the plastic strips in an ICF wall, no strapping needed. More on that in hanging things on ICF walls.

Termites

Termites in Ontario: Where They Are and What the Code Asks

Ontario does have termites. The eastern subterranean termite is an introduced species here, and the Nature Conservancy of Canada lists established pockets in older Toronto neighbourhoods and Scarborough, Guelph, Elora, Fergus, Windsor, as far north as Kincardine, and along the shoreline at Point Pelee and Pelee Island. Some of those municipalities have termite bylaws and control programs.

I have not found a published termite area for the Simcoe County and Georgian Bay townships we build in. That can change, so if you are building elsewhere or are unsure, call your township building department and ask whether your lot is in a termite area.

What the code asks in termite areas

Where termites are known to occur, the code (Article 9.3.2.9) requires structural wood within 18 inches (450 mm) of the ground to be treated, unless the supports are fully visible for inspection or termite barriers are installed. Guelph, for example, tells owners in former termite areas to keep decks and porches up on concrete and to use treated wood near grade.

What termites do to ICF

Foam is not food to a termite, but research cited by ICF Magazine found they will tunnel through untreated foam to reach wood, and the foam hides them while they do it. The concrete core is not hurt. The wood floors, sill plates and roof above it are what is at risk. That is why ICF is not “termite-proof” and why the details below matter even where termites are rare.

Our real pests

Carpenter Ants and Mice: The Gaps They Really Use

Around Georgian Bay, the pests I actually think about are carpenter ants and mice. Carpenter ants do not eat foam either, but builders report finding them nesting in rigid foam, usually near a moisture source like a leak or wet wood. Mice will chew through almost anything to get somewhere warm.

They get in through the same few places every time:

  • Exposed foam at grade behind decks, under steps and where cladding stops short.
  • The top of the wall where the sill plate and floor framing meet the concrete.
  • Service penetrations: hydro, water line, gas, dryer vent, heat pump line set, hose bibs.
  • Garden beds and woodpiles stacked against the wall, which keep the foam damp and give ants a highway.

The fixes are boring and cheap: cover all exposed foam above grade with a hard finish, seal every penetration, keep mulch, firewood and branches off the wall, and fix leaks fast. Moisture is the common thread with ants, which is why water management in ICF homes is really pest control too.

Below grade

Below-Grade Protection: Membranes, Parging and Treated Foam

Below grade, the same layers that keep water out do most of the pest work. Here are the options and how they stack up.

Waterproofing membrane

A self-adhered membrane goes on the foam below grade. BuildBlock and ICF Magazine report some membranes have been tested as termite resistant, such as Colphene ICF, Polyguard XT and Quad-Lock’s MDPEEL 40.

Protection above grade

Where foam is exposed between the ground and the cladding, it gets a hard coat, parging or a protection board so ants and mice cannot just walk in.

Insect-treated foam

Some brands have sold foam treated against insects. ICF Magazine reports borate in EPS was not enough and one treatment has been discontinued. Ask your supplier what is actually available.

In true termite country, builders also use stainless steel mesh, soil treatments and an inspection strip, a band of foam left off above grade so mud tubes can be seen. Coatings on their own do not stop termites, so most people combine methods.

For the waterproofing itself, read ICF basement waterproofing, and for drainage at the footing, foundation drainage in Ontario.

Our checklist

What to Check Before Backfill

Once the dirt goes back, every mistake below grade is buried. These are the things I walk before the excavator comes back:

  1. Membrane is continuous, lapped the right way and sealed at corners, ties and penetrations.
  2. Every pipe and conduit through the wall is sealed, inside and out.
  3. Footing drains are in, wrapped and graded to an outlet.
  4. The transition from membrane to above-grade protection is planned, with no bare foam left at grade.
  5. No wood scraps, form lumber or bracing left in the backfill zone. Buried wood is an ant buffet.
  6. Final grade will slope away from the house.
  7. Photos of every wall, with a tape in the shot, for your records and your insurer.

For more on how ICF stands up to tough conditions, see ICF for extreme climates, the bigger list of benefits of ICF over traditional homes, and common questions on insulated concrete forms. If your insurer asks about fire, our page on ICF insurance, appraisal and resale covers what to ask. Or go back to the ICF Homes in Ontario guide.

Free book

How to Build a Home Without Going Broke

Not ready to call anyone yet? Fair enough. Read the book first: the costly mistakes I have watched people make over 45 years of building, and how to avoid every one of them. Free PDF, straight to your inbox.

Questions people ask

FAQ

Is an ICF house fireproof?
No house is fireproof. The foam on an ICF wall is combustible, but the reinforced concrete core carries tested fire-resistance ratings. Nudura’s Canadian listing, for example, gives 2 hours for a 4-inch core and 4 hours for a 6-inch core with gypsum board as specified.
Does the foam in an ICF wall have to be covered inside?
Yes. The building code requires foam plastic in a wall to be protected from the inside of the house, normally with drywall. That usually includes an unfinished basement. Ask your building department about crawl spaces.
Can termites get into ICF foam?
Termites do not eat foam, but they can tunnel through untreated foam to reach wood, and the foam hides them. In termite areas, ICF walls need protection such as tested membranes, barriers and an inspection plan.
Are there termites in Simcoe County?
Ontario’s established termite pockets are in places like Toronto, Guelph, Elora, Fergus, Windsor, Kincardine and Point Pelee. I have not found a published termite area for the Simcoe County townships we build in, but ask your township building department to confirm for your lot.
Do carpenter ants and mice nest in ICF?
They can if they get in. Ants are drawn to foam near moisture, and mice chew through most materials. Cover exposed foam above grade, seal every penetration, keep wood and mulch off the walls and fix leaks quickly.
What should be checked before backfilling an ICF foundation?
Check that the membrane is continuous and sealed, every penetration is sealed, footing drains are in, no bare foam will be left at grade, no wood scraps are in the backfill, and the final grade slopes away. Take photos of every wall.

Keep going

More in this topic: ICF Facts and Myths

See all 12 steps of building a custom home, with every guide on the site  |  Straight answers: hours, payments, warranty, where we build

How to Build a Home Without Going Broke

Building a home in Ontario? Don't go in blind.

Get the free book How to Build a Home Without Going Broke — the costly mistakes most people make, and how to avoid them. Instant PDF to your inbox.

Real Enbridge bill: even in the coldest month, our ≈3,000 sq ft ICF show home cost just $117.45 to heat — kept at 20 °C (the month before: $99.21). See the actual bill → Unoccupied show home, heating only; your costs vary with size, finishes and use.
See a Completed ICF Home